What Do Peahens Really Want?

Of all, there was the technique of remaining immersed long enough to hear him. My 3-millimeter wetsuit was made from neoprene, a rubber instilled with small gas bubbles, and I felt as resilient as a cork. I was off the coast of Mo’orea, a little island in French Polynesia, drifting on the deep cerulean-blue sea.

I might simply make him out in the range: the faint white summary of pectoral fins and underbelly, a ghostly shape of a male humpback whale suspended vertically, nose pointing down to the ocean flooring. He was a huge school bus of an animal overshadowed just by the ocean itself, yet whose tune commanded the terrific stretch. His plaintive chant– rising high notes disrupted with bass staccatos that triggered my flippers to vibrate– was enhanced by the walls of the barrier reef. I was getting cold, however the satisfaction of his tune subdued my numbing limbs. I wished to keep myself in the existence of charm for simply a minute longer.

This story is from “The Hot Issue,” the most recent from Nautilus
To get it in print, sign up with by Nov 30

Charm. Did other whales off the coast of Mo’orea hear appeal in the tune? Do other animals sense charm?

None besides Charles Darwin believed so. He thought animals got satisfaction from appreciating shapes, colors, patterns, and sounds. On sees to the Zoological Gardens in London, he took pleasure in the peacocks’ embellished, rainbowlike plumes, and pictured that the peahens appreciated the peacock’s tail “as much as we do.” Birds weren’t the only nonhuman aesthetes. Darwin believed spiders had an eye for charm, too. He mused that given that we progressed from a typical forefather, it’s possible that a lot more life in the world might have a “taste for the lovely.”

The biological procedures for how this may work stayed a secret to him. In On the Origin of Speciesreleased in 1859, Darwin circled around the riddle of how life developed from a typical forefather through natural choice, and later on, in The Descent of Manhe was worried about the nature of animals’ sense of charm. The very first was resolved a century later on with the discovery of hereditary inheritance through DNA. The 2nd riddle is still an open concern.

Many researchers after Darwin– biologists specifically– dropped the concern completely. Victorians didn’t like the concept that the gratitude of appeal, frequently thought about proof of the soul, might be shown monsters. There was likewise growing agreement amongst researchers that nonhuman animal characteristics and habits might be described through the evolutionary objectives of sex, food, and shelter alone. Even now it’s consulted with suspicion. Charm, the presumption goes, remains in the eye of the beholder, who can just be human.

Modern-day evolutionary biologists have actually collected proof that animals from baboons to birds, honeybees to fish, may have a sense of appeal. As squishy as that may sound, a big body of research study in psychology, neurobiology, and computational neuroscience deals with appeal as an empirical phenomenon that can be specified and evaluated. Many of this research study focuses on people, researchers think there are strong parallels that can be drawn to nonhuman animals.

Tamra Mendelson, a teacher of evolutionary biology and behavioral ecology at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, is a leader in the field. She’s heard all the criticisms of her work being anthropomorphic. One day, after she lectured proposing that nonhuman animals share brain procedures with us that associate with experiencing charm, an associate approached her and stated, “You understand, this is all truly fantastic however simply drop the appeal part.”

“I’m not going to drop it,” Mendelson stated to me just recently with a warm laugh. “Beauty is genuine. It’s a genuine experience. You have it. He has it. We’re all animals, and we have it.”

In what methods, however, do animals notice appeal? What function does it play in breeding, in adjustment and development? Mendelson and her coworkers respond to those concerns and boldly propose that charm is its “own self-dependent source of satisfaction,” as they compose in a 2025 paper, “On the biological basis of charm.” We’re not the only ones on this world to take pleasure in something merely for its appeal. Animals too may experience charm for charm’s sake.

DARTING BEAUTY: The remarkable color scheme of darter fish can not be described merely as camouflage from predators or breeding signals. CREDIT: Dhester88/ Wikimedia Commons

Mendelson didn’t study charm at the start of her clinical profession. She was struck by it rather. While a college student at Duke University, she had a stint in between 1993 and 1994 studying lemurs at the Duke Lemur Center, where she discovered herself chasing the primates in the cold to tape-record whether the dominant woman gets to be the hottest by remaining in the middle of the huddle.

Her luck altered when a coach handed her a lot of documents on darters, a fish types belonging to North America discovered in the shallows of streams and lakes. Mendelson understood she ‘d discovered her perfect prospect. Darters might be studied in a lab fish tank that recreates their natural environment, and she might view them while seated with a cup of coffee. That wasn’t the only perk. It was likewise their appearances. “I can’t stand it, they’re so gorgeous,” she stated.

Throughout reproducing season, male darters, such as the sweet darter of West Virginia, are so remarkably colored and noticeably patterned that it’s difficult to peel your eyes away. Even on a computer system screen they’re enchanting: Their tummies are sprinkled with red surrounded in gold, their tails and backs are painted with shimmery blue-green, and their dorsal fins alternate dynamic orange and blue. The darter was Mendelson’s peacock. And much like Darwin, a concern hovered in Mendelson’s mind: Why do they appear like this? “I studied the function of mate option in speciation, and absolutely nothing made good sense,” she stated.

Mendelson was doubtful that the males’ coloring and pattern functioned as camouflage to mix into the environment and conceal them from predators. Their resplendence made the animals more, not less, noticeable by predators. The camouflage angle likewise stopped working to describe why the women weren’t colored like the males. Would not they require camouflage security the most? They are the ones with the eggs, after all, and getting demolished would put the types at threat.

Mendelson likewise wasn’t convinced that the ornamental functions simply indicated “excellent genes”– likewise the traditional description for the peacock’s plumage. The excellent genes theory goes that a tremendous and fantastic screen of tail plumes takes a great deal of metabolic energy to construct and preserve, and a weak or ill male would not have the ability to both subsist and have wonderful feathering. Simply put, the more prodigious the plumage, the much healthier the male and the higher opportunity his offspring will be healthy, too. If these functions were just signals of the males’ hereditary physical fitness, then we need to anticipate them to be more like “cars and truck alarms and stop indications,” Mendelson stated. Noticeable however not ornate.

Mendelson was captivated by evolutionary biologist Richard Prum’s argument that a gratitude of appeal was associated with animals’ mate choice, and she “liked the concept of a visual sense.” His theory didn’t go far enough. Prum, she stated, “does not use any description for the specific style of a signal.” It does not describe why a fin or plume is ornately patterned in the method it is. At this moment in her profession, Mendelson remembered, she stayed “baffled by the styles.”

BIOLOGIST IN THE HOUSE: Tamra Mendelson understands she can be viewed as trespassing in viewpoint by studying appeal. As an evolutionary biologist, she stated, “I can help us understand beauty in a totally different way.” CREDIT: Photo Courtesy of Tamra Mendelson

But this changed one summer day in Anchorage in 2015. Mendelson was at the University of Alaska for the annual meeting of the Animal Behavior Society, and attended a talk by Julien Renoult, an evolutionary biologist and cognitive scientist at the French National Center for Scientific Research.

Renoult began his career as a behavioral ecologist studying the fruit of fig trees in Madagascar. During his fieldwork, he noticed how certain birds and monkeys were drawn to the brilliantly colored green, orange, purple, and red fruits. He wondered why color and patterns might attract animals. When he looked for answers, he only came across studies on humans. “In nonhuman animals we had nothing,” Renoult said. 

In 2012, Renoult joined a lab in Paris that specialized in the history and philosophy of aesthetics. He spent the next three years poring through the literature on humans’ taste for beauty, while brainstorming how it could be tested in animals. “People thought I was doing strange things,” he said, but “this is something that we can study with a classic scientific approach.” 

He came away from his time at that lab with a significant insight—one that he believed helped link ornaments and mate choice in animals, and one in which animal appreciation of beauty is key. But how can you possibly crawl into the mind of another species, such as a peahen, to know whether she has a deeper appreciation for the peacock’s brilliant patterning and not just his sex appeal? You do it indirectly, and Renoult devised a clever hack. 

Renoult and his team trained a computer algorithm to process photos of landscapes—forests and sweeping countryside scenes—the way that a human retina and visual cortex would.

Neuroscientists have long known that brains compress information into fewer neurons to save energy, a phenomenon called “efficient processing.” It would cost us too much energy and time to have a neuron fire for each distinct feature of a habitat. Instead, we have specialized neurons that code for patterns in nature such as verticality, symmetry, and roundness. Over time, our brains become tuned to these patterns in our environment. It’s a shortcut that helps us quickly determine whether a place is familiar and safe. It’s also a bias our brains have for these features, and it looks for them everywhere. 

The researchers then fed the algorithm photos of women, and had it process their faces using the same vocabulary it built from processing the landscapes. Renoult noticed that some of these faces were processed quickly by the algorithm, requiring very little code. Since the algorithm is a simulation for how our brain works, this finding suggests that our brains encode landscapes and faces in a similar way.

Next, Renoult asked a group of 169 men to rate the same photos of women on a scale of 1 to 20 on attractiveness. He predicted that the more efficiently the algorithm processed a face, the higher the men would rate that face’s attractiveness. He was right. This indicated that “beauty is determined by a particular way of processing information,” he said. Beauty is not a property of an object, but rather the result of an activity in the brain.

Renoult’s study also suggested we find certain faces attractive because they share features with landscapes. Our visual cortex is ancient and evolved to help our forebears’ brains find patterns in their environment. And we are not the only animals with visual cortices that process information in an efficient manner. This compression can emerge and spread through a population over evolutionary time from repeated exposures to the environment, becoming encoded into the genome. Scientists have observed this coding “in all animals, even in invertebrates,” Renoult noted. It’s possible that snails are aesthetes.

While Renoult shared these ideas in the 2015 talk in Alaska, it dawned on Mendelson that she now had a hypothesis she could test. Maybe one reason the female darters were attracted to male darters wasn’t only because they found them arousing, but because their patterning resembled the environment that their brains had adapted to. Maybe attraction between mates in the animal world isn’t always about sex.

STAR POWER: Striking regularity in an animal pattern, like the star-shape tail of the greater sage grouse, can trigger pleasure. CREDIT: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Mendelson and Renoult have found a basis for their theory in many fields, notably neuroaesthetics, the interdisciplinary field that locates our experiences of the arts in the brain. “We’ve evolved from common ancestors, so a lot of our brain architecture is similar,” Mendelson said. Added Renoult, “Everything that characterizes a judgment of beauty in humans—the machinery at least—is present in nonhuman animals.”

With the use of brain scans, scientists studying neuroaesthetics in 2023 reported that when we say something is beautiful, a region deep in our midbrain, the mesolimbic system, generates a feeling of pleasure. Given we share the same basic neural machinery with all vertebrates, studies have shown that some insects, including bees, might have a similar reward system.

The pleasure of beauty is linked to processing information with ease, the same activity in the brain that Renoult discussed in his 2015 talk. Psychologists refer to the pleasure of information-processing as “fluency,” which they equate with beauty. This fluency, inherited from our evolutionary past (coded into our genome) and individual life experiences, can explain why there seems to be some universal qualities that characterize beautiful things, like symmetry.

It also explains why there might be shared aesthetic preferences across species. 

A study published this year investigated whether our taste in sounds overlaps with other species’ aural affinities. Turns out, we have the same appreciation for male frog songs that female frogs do. The lower-frequency calls embellished with “trills,” “clicks,” and “chucks” thrill us all, as does the female crickets’ preference for classic “chirps” over “purrs.” We also appear to have similar visual preferences with other species. A 2023 study suggested that jumping spiders like abstract images that contain similar spatial statistics, such as the changes in light and dark across an image, found in natural scenes that we like.

Another key point of Mendelson’s and Renoult’s thesis is that beauty is “disinterested.” When you experience beauty, you’re not concerned about what it’s going to give you beyond the immediate pleasure of appreciating it. The moment you begin to think about what you want, you’ve slipped into desire. Psychologists distinguish the two states as “liking” and “wanting.” Liking is linked with calming neurotransmitters, such as opioids and endocannabinoids; wanting is associated with arousal and dopamine. 

But if the experience of beauty isn’t goal-oriented, then it seems irrelevant to the purpose of survival. To put it another way: How does beauty make any evolutionary sense? 

The experience of beauty is an adaptive trait, Mendelson explained, but not necessarily for sexual purposes: “The whole process evolved in a different context than sexual communication.” That context is the environment. 

Because our brain rewards us with pleasure when we discover patterns and regularities in our surroundings, we are encouraged to continue gathering information. And because our brains are biased toward these patterns, we will find beauty in places unrelated to survival—like on a museum wall or the red carpet. An animal’s experience of ornamental beauty, Mendelson said, is an aesthetic experience not unlike our own, which doesn’t have to involve sexual selection.

Not that beauty has nothing to do with sex. Mendelson explained that beauty can indeed be part of the mating ritual. Although a sense of beauty evolved independently of sex selection, her hypothesis is that it’s “being exploited by sexual actors.” The female darter selects a male whose patterns are as pleasurable to process as those in her environment. Although liking and wanting have different functions, they’re not mutually exclusive. The stunning qualities of a male peacock’s tail give the peahen another reason to stick around, even if she hasn’t made up her mind whether he is boyfriend material.

KEY OF LIFE: Turns out, humans have the same appreciation for male frog songs that female frogs do. We get the same thrills. CREDIT: Macropixel / Envato

Innes Cuthill is a behavioral ecologist at the University of Bristol in the United Kingdom who studies adaptive traits in animals, notably coloration. He agrees with Mendelson and Renoult—and Darwin—that human traits can be a guide to understanding animals. “I’m certainly with Darwin in seeing that there’s continuity in emotional states, as well as physical processing and physiology, between other animals and us,” Cuthill said. “I mean, it would be very strange if there wasn’t continuity.”

But Cuthill worries comparing our experience of beauty to animals’ is a step too far. “I don’t necessarily accept that animals are experiencing emotions in the same way as us, and it’s probably impossible, really, to have any sort of subjective understanding of how that might feel,” he said. 

Cuthill also questions Renoult’s and Mendelson’s theory that an efficient use of brain energy necessarily connotes pleasure, which leads to an adaptive trait. It’s a jump from measuring an animal’s physiological response, he said, “to saying, ‘Ah, that’s why peacocks have evolved beautiful tails.’” Cuthill doesn’t question the veracity of an experiment showing animals can be either calmed or aroused. He challenges whether the experiment proves attraction. “It doesn’t tell us where the positive axis is, that something should be attractive,” he said.

Currently, Mendelson and Renoult are embarked on a new experiment. They plan to expose female darters to silhouettes of darters with a series of features similar to the environment to see which the fish spend more time actively observing. Their hypothesis remains: Should the fish prefer the images with similar properties to landscapes and endocannabinoids flood their brains, that provides evidence that an animal can exhibit the behavior and biochemical signatures of appreciating beauty.

This past June, Mendelson and Renoult joined an international group of biologists, neuroscientists, philosophers, and artists at the University of Antwerp to discuss LUCAE, “the last universal common aesthetic experience.” It’s a term Jan Verpooten, a research manager at the Antwerp Research Institute for the Arts and the group’s organizer, coined as a play on LUCA—“last universal common ancestor”—the holy grail of evolutionary biologists. 

Verpooten, a double doctorate in biology and philosophy, brought the group together to explore the deepest hint of aesthetic capacity in the tree of life. To his mind, it exists among the Bilateria—animals with a central axis and left and right symmetry who have neural processing and seem to experience pleasure. We’re among the Bilateria, but so are worms. So are 99 percent of animal species on Earth today.

If the biologists are right that a taste for beauty isn’t exclusive to humans, that most creatures experience it—it feels like a radically new way to see life on Earth. Like all great de-centerings, there is that moment of awe. We are among the 20 quintillion individual beings alive right now who at any given moment might be taking in something they find wondrous, and I can’t help but think: Isn’t that beautiful?

Delighting in NautilusRegister for our complimentary newsletter

Lead Image: Wirestock/ Envato


Discover more from PMN S.P.O.R.T.S - A PRIME MEDIA NETWORK BRAND

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img