I desired previous Security Branch (SB) officers Joao Rodrigues, Neville Els and Seth Sons to be held responsible in accordance with Judge Billy Mothle’s judgment.
After criminal cases were opened versus the 3 in October 2017, I non-stop pursued the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), asking for development reports on the examinations.
For 6 months, I was offered the runaround over the Rodrigues case before it was described the director of public prosecutions (DPP) in South Gauteng, Johannesburg, supporter Andrew Chauke, for a choice.
Rodrigues prosecution: A trial that never ever started
Within 3 months, Chauke’s workplace designated private investigators and district attorneys to perform additional examinations.
On July 30, 2018, Rodrigues was charged with murder and beating or blocking completions of justice. He was given bail of R2,000.
His very first court look for the criminal trial was arranged for Sept. 18, 2018, however the trial never ever started.
In March 2019, his legal group brought an application for an irreversible stay of prosecution before a complete bench of the South Gauteng High Court.
The application centred on Rodrigues’ argument that the NPA’s almost 50-year hold-up in charging him with murder infringed on his constitutional right to a reasonable trial, as offered under Section 35( 3 ), checked out with Section 12 of the Constitution.
His legal group likewise argued that standing trial at the age of 80, almost 5 years after the occurrence, infringed on his right to self-respect. His weakening memory was amongst the other elements pointed out.
Rodrigues had actually not used for amnesty before the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), his legal charges were paid by the state.
In May 2019, the High Court dismissed his application.
Claims of political disturbance in TRC cases
Throughout the court procedures, affidavits I sent through my legal counsel raised accusations of political disturbance in the suppression of TRC-related cases.
Senior NPA authorities promote Chris Macadam and Dr Torie Pretorius likewise sent affidavits on behalf of the very first participant, the nationwide director of public prosecutions (NDPP).
Their affidavits supported accusations of political disturbance and consisted of documentary proof.
In May 2019, I sent an application under the Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA) to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development to develop just how much the state had actually invested in Rodrigues’ legal representation, consisting of 2 senior supporters and advising lawyers.
A reaction got in November 2019 exposed that the state had actually paid more than R3.5 million towards his legal expenses.
Regardless of subsequent ask for details, the last quantity invested stays unidentified.
Rodrigues passes away before dealing with trial
Rodrigues’ legal group appealed the High Court’s choice to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in Bloemfontein.
The appeal was heard practically in November 2020.
In June 2021, the SCA dismissed his appeal. Rodrigues consequently looked for to interest the Constitutional Court in Braamfontein.
After 19 court looks, the criminal matter was eliminated from the court roll following Rodrigues’ death in September 2021.
He passed away without standing trial for Timol’s murder, leaving the concern of his criminal responsibility unsettled.
In May 2022, I lodged a problem with the Office of the Chief Justice (OCJ), asking for an examination into the extended hold-ups in hearing Rodrigues’ appeal.
The workplace reacted that, since the Constitutional Court had actually dismissed the Rodrigues matter on Feb. 24, 2022, and provided a court order, the grievance fell outside the required of the nationwide grievances officer.
Els and Sons: Prosecution deserted regardless of inquest findings
In his 2017 judgment, Judge Mothle advised that the conduct of previous Security Branch officers Neville Els and Seth Sons be examined even more, with a view to bringing proper charges.
Both officers had actually rejected understanding of detainees being attacked at John Vorster Square (JVS).
Throughout the 2017 inquest, Kantilal Naik affirmed that Els was amongst the officers who had tortured him.
In Sons’ case, 6 affidavits from previous detainees included claims that he had tortured them.
In spite of criminal cases being opened versus both officers in October 2017, the DPP in North Gauteng, Pretoria, chose in May 2020 not to prosecute them.
The choice was taken without acquiring extra declarations from the called witnesses, although they had actually sent affidavits throughout the 2017 inquest.
In June 2020, an application was sent to NDPP supporter Shamila Batohi, asking for an evaluation of the choice by DPP supporter Baloyi.
In February 2023, a choice was made to prosecute Els and Sons.
In July 2023, I was notified that prosecution was no longer thought about “possible” and that the cases had actually been closed.
Deaths and illness hinder prosecution efforts
The NPA discussed that Kantilal Naik had actually passed away which district attorneys had actually hoped proof from Salim Essop would make it possible for the state to construct a case versus the implicated.
Essop’s statement was anticipated to be supported by inconclusive evidence from other witnesses who would affirm about the attacks and abuse they apparently experienced at the hands of security cops at John Vorster Square.
Tries to acquire a sworn declaration from Essop, who lived in London, were not successful due to the fact that of his weakening health.
As an outcome, the state said it was not able to present proof from essential witnesses.
This description came 5 years and 9 months after the criminal cases versus Els and Sons had actually been opened.
Fifty years of unanswered concerns
When Ahmed’s buddies celebrated the 55th anniversary of his death on Oct. 27, 2026, I picked not to participate in. Rather, I commemorated my uncle independently.
On Nov. 11, 2021, I had actually composed to President Cyril Ramaphosa, explaining 5 years of tricks, lies, cover-ups and dead ends.
Every advance, I informed him, appeared to raise another wave of unanswered concerns– concerns that stay unsolved.
Because letter, I advised the president of a declaration provided by the FW de Klerk Foundation declaring an “casual contract in between the ANC management and previous operatives of the pre-1994 federal government”.
Ramaphosa had actually played a leading function in the historical settlements along with Roelf Meyer and others.
I attracted him to divulge any info he had about the supposed contract and whether it had actually affected the handling of apartheid-era prosecutions.
5 years later on, I have actually still gotten no action.
The pursuit of justice for Ahmed Timol has actually been marked by landmark legal findings, extended hold-ups and the deaths of essential figures before they might be brought to trial.
For me, the unanswered concerns stay an agonizing suggestion that, regardless of the 2017 inquest judgment, the complete fact has yet to emerge.
Imtiaz Cajee is Ahmed Timol’s nephew and the author of Timol: Quest for Justice (2005) and The Murder of Ahmed Timol: My Search for the Truth. He is dealing with his 3rd book.
The views revealed do not always show those IOL.
This short article was very first released by The National.
IOL
Discover more from PMN S.P.O.R.T.S - A PRIME MEDIA NETWORK BRAND
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





