After the ICJ Verdict, What for Dhaka?

Asia-Pacific, Crime & & Justice, Education, Gender, Gender Violence, Headlines, Human Rights, Migration & Refugees, TerraViva United Nations, Trade & & Investment Viewpoint

DHAKA, Bangladesh, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) – The world’s greatest court has actually provided a historical legal and ethical success. It does not get anymore conclusive than this. On 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) discovered that Myanmar dedicated genocide versus the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State. It is the very first time the court has actually held a state accountable for devoting genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. By a 9– 6 bulk, the judges likewise discovered that Myanmar stopped working to avoid and penalize genocide. The ICJ has actually promoted the Rohingya. The judgment is last, and there is no place delegated appeal. Turning this decision into a safe journey home will take political muscle that the court itself does not have. The global neighborhood needs to act now.

Dr Mohammad Zaman

A decision 7 years in the making

The case was generated November 2019 by The Gambia, a little West African state without any direct connection to the criminal offenses, backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The court analyzed the armed force’s 2017″clearance operations”in information: an approximated 10,000 Rohingya eliminated, and almost 400 towns, about 40 percent of those in 3 northern towns, partially or completely damaged before being bulldozed and constructed over. It concluded that Myanmar’s security forces purposefully eliminated members of the group, triggered them major physical and psychological damage, and enforced steps planned to avoid births.

Checking out the judgment, ICJ President Yuji Iwasawa stated: “The proof of ruthless acts of sexual violence and the targeting of kids for violence in Rohingya neighborhoods likewise supports a reasoning that there was a desire to ruin the structures of the group. The organized nature of these actions even more suggests a sensible reasoning that Myanmar showed genocidal intent.”

A legal and ethical triumph

The legal weight of this judgment is difficult to overemphasize. In the 2007 Bosnia case, the court discovered that Serbia had actually stopped working to avoid the Srebrenica genocide however stopped short of holding it accountable for dedicating genocide. This time there is no such hedge. The court likewise explained that genocidal intent can exist together with other goals, consisting of military ones. That damages Myanmar’s enduring claim that it was just combating a revolt.

The ethical success matters simply as much. For years, the Rohingya have actually been rejected citizenship, restricted to camps and dismissed by Myanmar’s generals. Now the world’s greatest court has actually put their suffering on the reliable record. UN Secretary-General António Guterres called the ruling a “effective acknowledgment of the Rohingya victims of genocide”. That acknowledgment can not be reversed, and it is a type of justice in its own.

What the court bought, and what it can refrain from doing

The court’s instructions are binding. Myanmar should stop any continuous offenses and pass legislation providing complete result to the Convention. It should examine, prosecute and penalize those accountable, and provide assurances that the atrocities will not take place once again. It needs to likewise offer restitution, consisting of the “safe, voluntary and dignified return” of displaced Rohingya to their homes and the reunification of households, and compensate the victims. Myanmar has 2 years to report on what it has actually done.

In useful terms, little is most likely to alter in the brief run. The ICJ has no police. Nor does it attempt people: it rules on conflicts in between states. The fate of Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, who managed the 2017 project and now heads the state, lies with the International Criminal Court. The ICC district attorney’s pending warrant application versus him now brings higher weight.

Enforcement and the politics of the veto

If Myanmar disregards the judgment, simply as The Gambia states it stopped working to abide by the court’s 2020 provisionary steps, The Gambia can take the matter to the UN Security Council under Article 94 of the UN Charter. This is where justice fulfills geopolitics. Any among the 5 irreversible members can ban action, and history provides little convenience. When the court ruled versus the United States in the Nicaragua case in 1986, Washington banned the resolutions requiring compliance. In 2007, China and Russia banned a draft resolution on Myanmar’s human rights record.

China holds the essential

No nation matters more here than China. Beijing is Myanmar’s crucial client. It has actually protected Naypyidaw at the UN, invested greatly in Rakhine and has actually served as a broker in between the junta and ethnic armed groups. Its top priority is stability along its financial passage to the Bay of Bengal, not responsibility.

The scenario on the ground makes complex matters even more. The junta has actually lost much of Rakhine State to the Arakan Army, and Myanmar has actually remained in chaos for many years. When the ICJ orders a safe go back to the Rohingya’s “home”, Naypyidaw can just state it no longer manages the area. Any reputable repatriation will for that reason need to be worked out with both the junta and the Arakan Army, probably with Beijing as guarantor. China desires Rakhine steady and its financial investments protect. If Dhaka and its partners can reveal that an organized, rights-based return serves that objective, China’s interests might associate the court’s orders.

What Bangladesh needs to do now

Bangladesh has actually brought the heaviest problem of a crisis it did not produce. About 1.4 million Rohingya now reside in the camps around Cox’s Bazar. Considering that 2017, repatriation talks have actually produced bit. The decision offers Dhaka a type of take advantage of it has actually never ever had before. It ought to utilize the decision to deal with allies to discover a convenient service.

Make the judgment the standard. Every repatriation offer must satisfy the court’s requirement: a safe, voluntary and dignified go back to the Rohingya’s initial homes, not to transit camps, with a clear course to citizenship.

Second, speak with whoever manages the ground. Dhaka needs to engage the Arakan Army pragmatically, together with Naypyidaw, so that any contract can be performed in Rakhine.

Third, deal with China, not around it. Bangladesh needs to push Beijing to ensure an offer and provide a steady, rights-based return as helpful for China’s financial investments.

4th, construct a union for compliance. Bangladesh ought to deal with The Gambia, the OIC, the 11 states that intervened in the event, ASEAN and Japan to keep Myanmar’s compliance before the UN General Assembly and Security Council, and to hold Myanmar to its two-year reporting due date.

Keep the Rohingya at the centre. Refugees need to have a voice in any settlement. Reparations should reach those residing in Bangladesh, and humanitarian financing, education and incomes in the camps should be secured while talks continue.

From decision to homecoming

The ICJ has actually done its part. It has actually called the criminal offense, determined the state accountable and set out what justice needs. The decision will not, by itself, send out a single household home. It alters the terms of every discussion about the Rohingya from this day on. Whether it ends up being a turning point or a footnote now depends upon what allies and states do next, beginning with Bangladesh.

Dr. Mohammad Zaman has actually composed thoroughly on the Rohingya crisis given that 2017. His current modified (co-editors Robert Anderson and Kawser Ahmed) book is entitled Rohingya Stories: History and Geopolitics in a Multipolar World (Springer 2025).

IPS UN Bureau


Discover more from PMN S.P.O.R.T.S - A PRIME MEDIA NETWORK BRAND

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img